It's curious that in the last episode Whitney defended Scotty, saying that she asked him to have sex. That reminds me how Noah and Alison remembered the sex on the car scene in the Pilot. Noah saw a rape and Alison justified the action showing us that she asked Cole to do rough sex.
These are things that happen in…

I think both Alison and Noah were right in their recollections about Cole. Even if it's what Alison told to the police why would she frame Cole if she remembered him only as a poor, innocent man who lost everything the whole time? What if the way things happened in her POV in the last episode is not a lie? How much…

Why would they make Cole the murderer if they were not telling that event to anyone? There is no reason for them to blame Cole. That means that they were really remembering Cole as a unstable, threatening man. Maybe it's the truth.

After the last episode i would not be surprised about that!
Think about how he framed Alison by telling her to call Noah, not Helen, and make him come to their house "because he just wanted to talk to him about what happened to whitney and scotty". LIAR! He didn't care about what Scotty did to a teenager. He used…

Cherry was not absent in Alison's version. She was there but disappeared when the Solloways came. To me it was Cole to ask her, with an excuse, to stay away….because he was going to use the gun. It makes sense.

Given that Alison and Noah were not telling that moment to someone or the detective, there is no reason for them to intentionally put Cole in a false bad light to justify something.
Both Alison and Noah's memories showed a threatening, insane Cole. What if it's part of the objective truth that somehow has to do with…

And maybe they are telling the truth.