Haha, fair enough about the People's, it was just meant to illustrate that, nevermind personal preferences, Josh can be seen as handsome by the largely accepted men's beauty norms. Actually so is Adam Levine in the symmetrical face, high cheekbones, etc way. Thus even though I certainly don't find him the Sexiest Man…

Well, Josh Charles was People's Magazine 7th Sexiest Man Alive in 2011, so while it's obviously purely subjective matter, you have to admit there could be something about the guy Alicia might find attractive..?
And while Will has many serious flaws. Misogyny? Really? About a guy whose only real friends seem to be women?

I think people who judge Will so harshly forget how pathetically lonely this guy's life actually is, and thus belittle how deeply recent developments affected him.
His sense of purpose has been wrapped around two women, one with whom he built what he thought was a home, a family, and in the end turned out to be just a…