That's the joke.

You're totally right. After watching, I considered whether they actually did want us to think it was him or just give us another out to think about. I'm still not sure they exactly fingered him, but just wanted to show us how often these cases aren't cut and dried.

Right, I meant to just say "evidence," but the implication of disposing the bag is clear to anyone paying half attention to the show. Which this dude wasn't. And then he complained about the stuff he missed as the show's fault.

I have been reading AV Club for years but had to sign up to address how horribly wrong you are. How can you complain and not be paying attention? They show him throw away they knife on video. He got in through one of the two places they showed allowed people in (and he was the BF…he probably had a key). He didn't see…