That was my theory too! That maybe those false images we saw of Eleanor's time on Earth were what she could've accomplished with Chidi in her life and that the soulmate thing is the real issue. That good people like Chidi and Tahani have less than ideal soulmates that essentially got pulled along for the ride.

Okay so I guess no one else is going to have as sappy of a guess as me for the Afterlife issues. BUT what if it's the soulmate formula causing the problem? Maybe up until now good people have tended to have good soulmates but for some reason these people don't and the lives and memories on the screen are the potential…

Your point is valid but your profile pic/username is the really winner here!