I think people who don't subscribe to one of the main tenets of the religion (that the Xmas story is a big fat lie) wouldn't describe themselves as JW, yeah. Am I so sure of that and care enough that I want to get into a big fight on the AV Club about it? Not so much.

Really? My childminder growing up was one and they're pretty all-or-nothing: you're doomed and going to hell or you follow the rules completely. I do like how everyone's keen to believe it's a conscious choice and not an oversight but I think it's more likely to be a new-for-S3 writer who hasn't learned all the…

Someone's probably said this in the 9 pages of comments already but why would a Jehovah's Witness buy a Muslim a Christmas present, exactly? Or did I miss an in-joke? That took me out of the story and I couldn't pay attention to the rest of of the scene. But I thought this episode was possibly the best of S3 so far,…