I think the problem is that they have tried to humanize the Governer too much by focusing on him leading Woodbury and his daughter while not focusing enough on the batshit crazy stuff he has one.

That's both an interesting observation AND a good rationalization. :)

Yeah, as I put in my edit I don't personally believe the Governor needs to be any more evil. I was just trying to offer a rationalisation for Rob's line of thought. It seems like he wants a Governor that just goes ahead and does evil stuff even when it wouldn't particularly benefit him. So far, the Governor has always…

I'm not denying that the Governor is evil, I'm arguing he's just not that scary, and thus he's not that effective a villain.