Not driven one yet, but did finally see the interior up close and they’re... not bad. Not bad at all.

This is the most correct answer. It also shows how ahead of its time the original GT40 was. I'm any context these designs look contemporary

Agreed. When this came out, it was such a departure from the New Edge that preceded it. Everyone fell in love with it, especially the boomer generation that it was clearly targeting. It was objectively better than the New Edge it replaced, and the competition for it.... was... um... where was the Camaro and the…

We have one and I adore it.

It’s hard to explain to kids these days how much this redesign blew us all away.

Winner!

The S197 Mustang, especially the Bullitt model in 2008/2009.

The R50-R53 Mini Cooper. Yes, much larger than the original, but captures its spirit and in exchange you got a car that could fit a 7' driver, and drove like a goddam go kart. So rambunctious, so fun. Just driving on a simple highway cloverleaf became a joy

Ford was on a roll in the early 2000's. I think the T-bird looked great, then came the Ford GT which was amazing. I even liked the F-150 design (inside and out) of that era. 

Bronco Sport gets a lot of undeserved hate for being a ‘glorified Escape’ but I think that in terms of design its a breath of fresh air in the CUV or SUV scene:

No... this is an example of them NOT getting it right. 

IMO, the Ford Flex is a retro version of a 1970s I-H Travelall, right down to the white roof.

Especially the 2-door.  Looks perfect. 

I don’t hate a lot of the retro designs, but I also don’t love them either. But, the Ford GT looks amazing.

New Ford Bronco. Looks modern yet with enough retro cues to look timeless and tie back into the old Broncos.
They also look better in person than in photos to me too. I really think Ford nailed it visually.

Plymouth Prowler

The Challenger hands down. Sure it’s alot bigger than it’s elder, but they captured the look extremely well. I wanted to say the new countach, but that’s a little too modern looking in respects to the old one and they didn’t even include the wing.

Why would anyone be scared to stop for the police? /s

It’s little brother the Nautilus is great-looking as well, including some really pretty color options.

This was Mazda during their peak “Zoom-Zoom” era. The first Mazda6 was such a solid, handsome design with a perfect mix of curves and edges.