I agree, and I am surprised the reviewer (and others) took Chuck at face value on this. The last time the tape was played was by Howard, and it was made very clear that "that's it, it's finished" and Howard still left it on for a good few more seconds before pressing stop. For the tape to be back at precisely the…

And it looked like he was still married when their mother died, he had a wedding ring on in the opening sequence of "Klick".

Sweet theory!

Can we get some love for Jimmy humming the "Rocky" theme after seeing Mike all beaten up? That made me chuckle.