Counterpoint : if you don’t read the comics, avoided the chatter and conjecture all summer and just watched the show last night, like I did, it was totally worth it.

When it’s your job to write up a review, though, the least you can do is look up the names when you’re done... it takes 2 seconds. I know it’s “petty” but in almost every single one of Rob’s reviews he either gets a name wrong, attributes something to the wrong character, completely misses a pivotal piece or dialog…

It really is striking the number of mistakes he made while recapping this episode. Attributing things the other two female Saviors said to the Alicia Witt character, Pablo/Paulo/Primo, it was gasoline, not oil. the zombies were in a hallway (to block the exit, duh) and not on the killing floor, it’s a rosary and not a…

Yes and also, it was the smoking lady who said “we’re all Negan,” not Alicia Witt. And the zombies were in a hallway, not the killing floor. And the guy’s name was Primo, not Pablo or Paulo. You’d think someone who reviews shows for a living would take some notes.

Most chillingly, Alicia Witt tells Carol this: “You’re not the good guys. You should know that.”

Carol’s sudden crisis of inhumanity doesn’t seem fully warranted by the events of the show.

All I wanna do is recognize Gabe for becoming a total badass after ASZ fell. Dude was quoting bible scriptures and laying his best sam jackson on motherfuckers before smiting them in the name of the lord.

The number 18 in Carol's book was the number of non-dead humans she's killed.

What is Morgan welding? I hope it’s a giant metal statue of a dove. That Negan uses to crucify people.

I am really excited that after all these years Carl finally learned to stay in the house. So proud of him.