I am sick of hearing about it?

That's the only scene that really made me go and think "yeah that's CG, no doubt",
But that's my point though: Inception was never fucking distracting like this and most of the really impressive crap WAS real.

And so okay, whatever if you think 2001 looks obvious.

I think this looks pretty obvious, sue me I guess.

I agree (on both points).

This is a good point but I only look at comments to videos I am interested in.

It's true most of youtube is full of retards, and this video was no different.

Yeah I think it all comes down to the camera work and how you expose the audience to the situation.

The disorienting nature of this scene is appropriate but I still get pulled out immediately because unlike ghost protocol (great movie btw), it doesn't really look like these actors are in space.

I know I've been listing…

Bang, you answered correctly.

Well that's cool.

I guess it is just me when I say it doesn't look very real.

Except I said the destruction IS in CG.
Maybe it seemed like I meant something else, but I know what I meant.

This is my personal favorite:

Don't get me wrong it looks relativity interesting, but what I am saying is that I have seen better space sets before in much older movies.

What I thought looked fake the most were the space suits themselves, it really felt like they scanned the actors face into a suit rather than doing most of it practically.

I need some references first.

I want to make this as inconvenient as possible.

Cerebro you say?

This is a good point, even if I still think 2001 did it better.

The only thing I think would definitely need to be done in CG though is all the crap getting destroyed lol.

Yeah I mean it's clearly hard as hell to emulate real zero gravity so why not to part of it real and the destruction in CG.
Like I said before, Inception did it pretty well without any CG and it looked fucking awesome.

You've heard of me and you have only been posting since Monday? (not even full 3 days)

What, did owls fly in through your window and tell you to 'watch out or Spike'?
xD

Your reaction doesn't surprise me.

It's like if I say anything bad about that game I get crucified lol.

At least I had something unbiased to say, and at least try to counter my opinion instead of just whining about it.

That's my job.

(I think?)

You should look at the youtube comments.

Full of people just flat out comparing it to Last of Us.

Well, sorry.

I think this looks better.

The CG is a bit too obvious, like just by looking at it I can tell almost nothing is really happening (as apposed to something elaborately practical and well done like Inception or 2001: a space odyssey.)