It would be awesome if the Riddler's out there right now, constructing a convoluted riddle where the ultimate answer actually is "ball point banana".

That "who are you?" from Dr. Cox was one of the first things I saw on Scrubs…it was awesome that they'd been regulars on the same show for 2 years, and their characters had never heard of each other.

That new model is probably also what saved "Chuck" the last couple of times.

Sometimes the spambot has a nice way of summarizing things quickly.

Yeah, I guess they're not going to have time to get to that storyline, which is disappointing.

Guess I'm disagreeing with almost everyone here, but I liked the ending twist.  It's an interesting use of the central premise, the kind of storyline that almost any other show couldn't attempt (Fringe could do it, maybe?).  It's also definitely something I did not see coming.

Awesome…this rivals the best of Frakes and Sirtis.

Ah, true, that's what I meant to say…thanks for clarifying.

That list is awesome…but even that doesn't cover all of the Janitor's lies.

That's a great description of it.  I have multiple family members with Alzheimer's and will probably get it myself eventually, but I saw nothing offensive about it, awesome gag.

I'm a big Scrubs fan, but I can't remember anything about "His Story" except the already mentioned scene where Cox is mentally cycling through a list of girls' names for JD (which is an awesome scene).

Not sure about this episode…I think I liked it more than Kevin, but it seemed like it could be a really great episode, and then it just sort of fizzled.

I liked the lampshading of the way they repeated the plot point of Gus's friends getting kidnapped.  Juliet and Shawn both realize it's an exact repeat of last year.

Interesting thought on the red/green color blindness.  Red/green color blindness is pretty common, I think…so I wonder if the showrunners chose those colors on purpose as a subtle thematic hint.  Maybe Michael has red/green color blindness.

Just my own personal reading, but the quotes I'm seeing from Killen, Gordon, and Isaacs so far all seem somewhat non-committal, like for now they've decided to write to the idea that one world is real and the other isn't, but they could easily change their mind later, if the show keeps going.

Agreed, the pilot was so good that I'll be sticking around for several episodes, give them a chance to figure out what they want the show to be.

Definitely…I can see how the events happening outside his knowledge could confuse the narrative, and hurt the show a bit.

Loved the ending.  I can tell by the responses here it's been a little controversial, but I'm glad they took a chance and went for it (I do like a good ambiguous ending).

I love Psych, and I like Kevin's reviews so far…I think he's on the mark this time.  This episode had some good parts, but it wasn't as funny as usual.  Everybody's acting was a little more broad than usual.  The writing was shaky too…Shawn makes some crazy jumps in logic sometimes, but he wouldn't normally accuse a…