Yes. I'm pretty sure I graduated the same year as the Creek crew (99), so Andie and I were the same age then. Now she plays a woman whose daughter is my age. (Lemon and George are 30ish, right?)

Maybe you're getting JJ Abrams vibe, because that was an Alias homage—I won't spoil it because I know they're recapping it right now, but it's virtually identical.  Except for one small detail.