You have a point there but if they hadn't bothered to explain what Jacob and MIB were going into the finale, I'd guess that you'd have a lot of angry LOST fans. This way, the mystery's out and in the open (and, bizarrely, people loved it) and the focus can be on the final survivors of 815.

It's hard to say…maybe the smoke monster is really MIB but simply stripped of its physical form?

not at all…I felt the same way and was suprised at the number of people/reviewers fawning at it. Parts of it were good but on the whole it was a ridiculous mess which stuffed a few necessary points as hastily as it could and spent the rest being embarassingly poor.

I'm not sure how that undermines my point…I mentioned that I enjoyed the story and the characters and all the positive reviews I've read have highlighted those two aspects of the game. If you find the story weak than that's your preference and not a fault of the narrative structure or plot since there may be many…

loved the game…
Did the reviewer play the whole game? If you did, care to expand a little bit on the characters? The story? The combat? And the overall purpose of the linearity? Care to justify the mediocre score you gave it? What's the C- for? The linearity? You could probably name hundreds of linear games which have…

resolved most of the second question upon re-watching the show…although the first is still a bit confusing

lost - plot arc questions
Hey guys,