It's funny, the only words you'd have to remove from the original post for me to agree with it exactly is "and most consistent."

DSM
DSM's first season had B- plotting with an A cast. DSM's second season hit me repeatedly in the face.

Dialogue
Why is unrealistic language a strike against Diablo Cody? From Buffy to Sports Night to Shakespeare, when have we ever demanded our art reflect the way people really talk?

Why does everyone think Rhadika is bringing anything to the table? My girlfriend has her up there too, but she rarely does anything good and is frequently at the bottom. I think she's racing Carla for the bottom, now that Ariane is gone, and I think Carla's got more going on.

Of COURSE they're going to I, Robot it up.

PTC
I've never been able to get up in arms about the PTC. When I went to their website, they seemed largely concerned with keeping adult programming out of the 8pm prime-time hour, and informing parents what potentially objectionable content is in different shows. I've never seen them trying to eliminate adult…

I love Stefan because he's in a completely different world from anyone else. He's one of the older guys, he's got more talent than anyone else, and he's picked out a lesbian who hates him for his next (3rd? 4th?) wife. He just does not fucking care.

Failure
I love Gossip Girl, but there's no way Schwartz and Savage are going to actually have much to do with this show. They're busy! So it's going to be farmed out to the same hacks who bring down 90% of shows that air.

How low? He literally might be arrested for war crimes if he ever leaves the country again. Let's see how many trips to Europe he takes in the next 20 years.

I thought the joke was that he's indestructable, in that no matter how many things he screws up, he will always have his defenders, and always feel justified in his own mind.

Are ALL chain pizza places nasty in your opinion? I like my Little Caesar's Hot 'n Ready just fine, thank you, and so does the rest of Detroit.

Check Facebook. Ha!

The 7th book dropped the series from being an ungradeable masterpiece to a B/B- in my eyes. The third and fourth books were astounding, but they were accidents.

This is a good book.
Tasha's been working here for a while!

Nitpick!
If she can spit well, wouldn't that mean she could trust him a considerable distance?

No kidding (re: BSG).

I always remember him as the ADA on Homicide.

It makes me wonder if the finale won't be about how Dex has to work harder to kill Miguel, but rather him trying to find a way to kill him extra hard.

Secret Abe Lincoln and the Imaginary Hammers.

Man, that's just sad. 4 days before my 23rd birthday, and I'm done.