Most egregious sin against mankind (probably): Casting Mandy Patinkin in a musical and not letting him sing (I'M LOOKING AT YOU, BARBARA STREISAND)

"very sparingly through the rest of the series"? When's the last decade you watched HBO?

Was Wesley Wyndam-Price's father in that video? That explains so much.

Man, the Caroline character is so amazing. I'm really glad they killed her off last season.

I, for one, loved 500 Days of Summer to bits.

He could even keep it in "The Second Coming". How about "What Rough Beast"? Or perhaps "A Gaze Blank and Pitiless as the Sun"?

Thanks Jake! Youda best.

Don't forget: "This is the part where you make a choice." What choice? Who's making a choice? If one of the potentials was like, "my choice is no," what would they have done? Didn't look like Little Miss Baseball Bat had a choice in the matter.

I don't understand this html formatting thing. Why is dropped italicized? Why, I ask you!?

I'm 20, I've never watched a soap opera, and I've heard of it. It can't be that dropped.

In all fairness, the first season of Twin Peaks is easily the greatest first season of any show ever. Really. It's a masterpiece. Which is largely what makes the second season so disappointing. With the qualification "Twin Peaks' first season," it can go on any list you want.

You think the last episode is the best of the second season? Or in general? Either way, I'm pretty sure you're wrong. It was good and everything, but Maddie's murder/Bob's reveal was better. Plus the entire first season.

He's playing an artist. Whose canvas is MURDER!

It's LADIES night!!!!!

Also liked When She Was Bad. One would likely be traumatized by dying, and it actually kind of foreshadows Buffy in S6.

I just think when he [SAME SPOILERS] shows up in Angel, it would have been a nice touch if he was going out with a dude instead of two ladies. Like, no big deal made, no coming out story, just evidence that he's progressed, not regressed, as a character.

I like "Nightmares" and "The Pack". As a season though, no, it's just silly, campy fun. "Angel" and "Prophecy Girl" are important. You can continue fast forwarding for a good chunk of early season 2 too. (tutu. hee.)

As you pointed out, he's a repressed homosexual. His devotion to Warren is pretty blatantly spelled out in light of that. I guess you could argue it's staying in the closet that might lead one to evil, not being gay in and of itself.

Is she a she? Have we decided that?

Git-r-done?