avclub-e1f700955d13ca1dab21b2c172199d78--disqus
ThePhantom
avclub-e1f700955d13ca1dab21b2c172199d78--disqus

Man, Jyhad. That remains the first and only game I quit halfway through learning and vowed never to play again. A few people later on told me it was a really rich and deep game, but it always seems needless arcane to me. However, Tasha, I trust your opinion far more then the people who previously told me it was good.

You've already covered my first two picks (Home and Sylvia). I almost want to throw a vote towards "33" from Battlestar Galactica. While not straight up horror, it was the consistent threat and draining of hope that made that episode terrifying.  You knew the Cylons were going to show up again after 33 minutes, but

Here here!

This might be the episode that does me in.  I was thinking your grade was higher than your review depicted, so I started with a C-.  But then the more I read the review and thought about the episode, the more I remembered how terrible it was and dropped to a D+.  There were elements I think I liked, but overall I was

I avoided this because the backdoor pilot was so bad.  So it's kind of fun, huh?  I'm guessing some kind of miracle was pulled off. Because that episode of Bones was pretty painful.