It does seem kind of stupid. I suggest Nora Jane Noone for the role. She hasn't done anything good since The Magdalene Sisters. And she's very pretty.

We're pretty Ruthless here on AV Club.

Well, I agree she lacks charisma, but to expect of all actresses to be drop-dead gorgeous is not really fair. They're actresses, not models. I would like to see more that look like real women, and I like her for not being perfect, even though she has the tendency of saying stupid things.

Woodley is pretty too, not always photogenic, but she has those big doe eyes, and in White Bird in a Blizzard is really beautiful, aided by make-up, lovely clothes and flattering angles. And she knows how to smile.

I'm not denying that westerns can be very good movies (as your list proves), and I like a few (The Proposition in particular, because it was awesome and Nick Cave is great), but it's just that I personally don't really enjoy watching westerns. I've watched so many of them (mostly run-of-the-mill ones, with John Wayne)…

Liam Neeson has an excuse for becoming The Geriatric Action Hero, his wife had just died and he needed to get his mind off things. What excuse does Sean Penn have? He doesn't even have the particular set of skills necessary to play this kind of roles. He's too fussy and pretentious.

If Kristen Stewart can win a Cesar award after Twilight and with her perpetually gloomy face, Shailene Woodley can escape unscathed too.

That hair was her best feature, thick and really pretty.

This is a beautifully written review and it convinced me to see this movie, even though I'm not fond of westerns.

I'm not exaggerating here, I'm more upset about that than I was when some of the writers left.

It's the combination between the false polite talk, the buggy, deranged eyes and that completely silly wig. And plus, Jonathan Tucker plays him.

Some commenters said last week that Katherine Hale isn't as scary as Mags Bennet, even though she is presented that way, because she didn't back up her air of menace. How's that shooting for backing up? The woman has ice in her veins. I love Mary Steenburgen in this and I'm annoyed her role isn't bigger. She could've…

It's Portuguese as spoken by drunk Italians.

I don't know if I'm ashamed, I'd say I find it definitely weird and a bit alarming, but I find Steve Buscemi pretty attractive. The guy is old enough to be my father, but hey, he has this unique charisma.

I'm an INTJ and I'm mostly not an asshole. I hope.

I would be more enthusiastic about whaling history if whaling were completely a thing of the past. As it stands now, reading about it only makes me too depressed.

So now Ryan Murphy populates his series with gorgeous guys he secretly dreams to be involved in an orgy with? I think we're in for a lot of Man Ass and homoerotic action.

I enjoyed reading your reviews ICP. You have a talent for writing, I must visit The Solute more often.

Eddie and Agustin were the best this episode. And why torture us by giving us Frank for just a scene this whole season? They should have left him out entirely, not bring him only for Agustin to profess his newfound zen way of being.

I'm not Patrick's biggest fan, but Megan was so cruel, judgmental and unfair with him. It's obvious she's frustrated with her own life, but she was a shrill, homophobic shrew this episode.