Part of me wants to know what the community grade would have been for that Agents of SHIELD episode. My blind guess is a C+ but I haven't read the review, seen the episode, or read more than a few of the comments.

B. Fun but the only part I loved was all the ranking (which should be no surprise)

A- and a B+ averaging to a B+

So was that a shoutout to our Myles?

Nice try tossin. If you want your grade to be counted you're going to have to give me a grade that you could have given this episode if the redesign never happened. ;)

Grade Thread
Post your grade for this episode here!

PDN gave it a B

Grade Thread
Post your grades here!

B for me. It's close to a tossup between B and B+ but the Winston plot was the only one that really connected with me.

Grade Thread
There were two episodes tonight but in order for me to count your grades you have to give me ONE grade because we're trying to make this as close to pre-redesign as possible. So if you thought the first episode was an A- and the second was an A, pick one or the other.

Also, many people (including myself) have been tweeting grades but I can't count those because I want it to be easy for anyone to check my math. So I encourage both tweeting your grade AND leaving a comment in the thread.

I guess I'm going to mostly stick to doing grade threads for shows I watch but I can do them if an episode deserves it, like it sounds like tonight's Person of Interest does. Right now I have one going for New Girl that has a B+ average which I suspect would be a B if the redesign didn't happen. People who have…

Can't count that since there is an even amount of grades between B and C. If you picked B- or C+ I could count it.

Just watched it. A-

I have to make a rule that I only include grades in the average if they reply to my comment because in large threads I won't have time to go through all the comments. So your grade will be included if you reply to my grade thread!

There used to be a time when you could give an episode an A+ but that was a few years ago. I'm trying to make it as similar to the design we had a week ago as possible.

Grading scale only goes up to A so I'll put you down for an A

Doing a grade thread in New Girl and I have a feeling it would have been more successful if I was one of the first people to post. Looking forward to notifications coming back!

Grade Thread
Post your grades here! I'll keep track of the community grade and update it periodically

"Community hasn’t even premiered yet and already we’re seeing people foolishly put it on the schedule for next year."
What?