So then is this its last season? So happy I gave up on this show before the previous season ended.

Nolan helps Victoria track down her son who happens to be someone we don't know, but he's exceptionally good looking (of course) and from the wrong side of the tracks and he hates his mother for giving him up to go to art school (who does that?!), so naturally he's far more sympathetic to Nolan. Sparks fly, he falls…

When and why did this show get moved to Saturday? Has NBC finally given up on it like so many of us did so long ago?

Since the writer of the episode was Ryan Murphy, I doubt Sam and Artie are channeling what he really thinks, but far be it for me to try and plumb the depths of that idiot's head. I think they made her a teacher for the same reason they made Rachel pregnant and then not, for the same reason they made Becky the one…

All I would say is that mentally unstable or not, if his one and only job is to watch Beth (kind of what monitor means after all) then he should have known something serious was wrong well before he needed to see a missing scar and a mysterious kid. I agree with Caroline here that he just really sucks at his job, and…

The only problem with Paul's "obligatory weekly nude scene" is that he hasn't really been nude since the pilot. I mean shirtless, sure, but is that really enough to justify his continued existence? I say kill him off, and then ship the actor out to Game of Thrones and put him in Little Finger's brothal so we can get a…

I'm taking issue with this nickname. I mean, I'm just sayin, pics or it doesn't exist. lol

@avclub-0304234e5dac07d007cf06c22b3f29c4:disqus I don't know that I'd go so far as to say Colin's going to be nothing more than a prop. He's one-dimensional at the moment, sure, but as they spend more time with him and dive deeper into him and Felix (or at least when he and Felix stop being nothing more than booty…

idk, I certainly see where Caroline is coming from. I think he feels a bit superfluous the deeper we get into the clone mythology. He doesn't have much of a place within it (it seems) so he stands to be little more than an inconvenient tie to Sarah's previous life. And the more about the clones we find out, the less…

I think I've given Paul all the benefit of the doubt I can. I was worried about his acting, but I made allowances due to how much of a powerhouse Maslany has been, but now I can't do that anymore, he's just bad. I was willing to assume he'd get interesting as a character once he started being more active, alas that's…

At least Vic is funny. His quiet "I'm good" after getting his finger cut off as the scene faded to commercial was priceless.

I agree, it was totally unethical, and I think Shelby acknowledged that too. I think the show presented that moment as more of a lapse in judgment brought on by loneliness, feeling a bit overwhelmed, and some of the innate charms of Puck. I would argue, however, that the show wanted to present it as simply something…

Yes Will is a teacher, but Will is a *bad* teacher. I'm not talking about his lack of compassion I'm talking about his general ineptitude. For Will to bring in an outsider to help on this matter would require him to show a level of competence we haven't seen him possess in 4 years. (This is the Spanish teacher who…

@avclub-06b6610df0c2a2d4be303f2d81e9e5d3:disqus that would be the argument against that line of thinking that I mentioned.

I'd forgotten about the Artie and Brit thing. I was thinking about Sam's stripping, but less in the sense of if he'd hustled and more in the sense of being objectified in such a fashion would have made him more sympathetic, but I can also see an argument against that line of thinking.

ok 2 things though. 1) You seem to be skating over the most important part of my statement which is that I don't buy that those 2 would say those things in that place at that moment. I think in that moment, seeing how hurt and clearly traumatized Ryder is by this story, Sam and Artie keep their mouths shut. Maybe they…

So the problem isn't a moral one, it's a purely legal issue?

I guess I just don't agree on the Tommy points (with the exception of the story about his mother which was a really wonderful moment for him). I don't find him interesting, I never have, I don't find him compelling, and I don't care about his relationship with Laurel. I also think a portion of this has to do with the…

That I agree with 100%, but under no circumstances do I feel that Puck's legal age should be viewed as "irrelevant." I think that there's a lot of difference between what happened to Kitty and Ryder and what happened between Shelby and Puck and a large amount of that difference is found in their ages. Not from the…

First of all: Ohhh that was Mondo! I was wondering, but I wasn't sure, and then I was frightened, and now I'm enlightened. lol