Thanks for taking the time to write all this. Generally, I agree with what you find to be faults with the show, but disagree on their impact to the show’s quality.

Also, I think this is more of a mistake than a subtle touch, but both the "forward" and "backward" buttons lead to "Top Movies of 2012".

Nice touch including an image of an actress who is the star of none of those shows.

It's not that weird when you consider it physically.  You have a common rankings axis at position 12 with an overall angular displacement of about 180 degrees.

Strike Back is sex and violence dialed up to awesome.

Is someone compiling these? Or have they been surrendered to the commenting ether?

Sorry.  The AV Club is certainly more evenly-mixed than most of cyberspace when it comes to genders, but I assume everyone is male anyway because internet….even in a Gossip Girls review.

Sorry.  The AV Club is certainly more evenly-mixed than most of cyberspace when it comes to genders, but I assume everyone is male anyway because internet….even in a Gossip Girls review.

…I don't remember what I voted for…hm.

Dungeonmasters?

Let this be a lesson to you: Jokes tear communities apart.

Cumberbatch?

They caused the mess in the first place.

I remember there being plenty of mistakes before in other reviews.  A true assessment requires a quantitative comparison of the mistake rate during and after Phipps' employment.  Please get on that.

I remember there being plenty of mistakes before in other reviews.  A true assessment requires a quantitative comparison of the mistake rate during and after Phipps' employment.  Please get on that.

Er, isn't the act of pointing to direct evidence supporting his assertion completely contrary to a "faith-based" analysis?

Er, isn't the act of pointing to direct evidence supporting his assertion completely contrary to a "faith-based" analysis?

IF I RIP OUT YOUR EYES I WON'T HAVE TO GUESS

If this persists, you'll never be in position to make a year-end list EVER AGAIN.

Stephen77, finally taking ass and kicking names.