I'm confused: just because we saw Jack Dobbs dig up a corpse and break off its finger does not exonerate him from being the killer. Is there a reason why we do not think this is Sonya's sister's body?

These are some of the most profound, fascinating interviews I have ever read. Thanks.

There were a lot of clues in the scenes between Pastor Mike & Linden where he established that he has never been believed by the authorities. He kept saying how no one believed that all he was doing was detoxing the girls he was suspected of kidnapping. And, that no one would believe him now that he did not kill the…

I am wondering what this character's arc is all about. Are we supposed to believe that he never claimed his innocence? And a clue to that is his choosing a much more gruesome method of execution than that which the state normally offers? So, do we think he was a "hardened Criminal" because of his father, the scumbag?…

I hope it is not going to be Koteas or Holder's dicky partner because they haven't even remotely made the case that either of these characters could be a serial killer. I mean, ostensibly, the killer should be someone who we can imagine taking more than a dozen lives. And, then there is Seward's wife. We do think the…

This is a really well-written, probing post. Thank you for your thoughtfulness.

I also love how they find a new clue, likethe militia guy, and they ONLY SEND RYAnN and the FBI chick. And, oh this time, of course, the FBI guy who was brutally attacked to within an inch of his life by the cult. I mean, no one else is available to follow a totally viable clue. In general, the way this show depicts…

I'm glad you brought this up, Assless Chaps. I was thinking about this conversation between Joe & Ryan (because, seriously, when I go to sleep on Monday nights, inevitably, I am plauged with thoughts about this show): What kind of wuss is Ryan that he has NOTHING WHATSOVER to say to Joe on the phone. I get it: YOU'RE…

I feel like we haven't payed sufficient attention to the fact that Molly, Ryan's girlfriend, is a Follower. Is Ryan just a terrible judge of character?

I live for this awesome AV Club The Following Reader Community. It's the only thing that keeps me waking up on Tuesday mornings.

I'm shocked that you didn't include the fact that Ryan's (ONLY) buddy is in Witness Protection, but RYAN KNOWS WHERE HE LIVES! I mean, I know Ryan is (WAS) in the FBI, but I thought the #1 rule of Witness Protection is that NO ONE knows where you live.

Yup, D+, that's what I thought. I actually enjoy these recaps & the comments. Makes the weird obsession that i have for this truly terrible TV show all the more time-wasting.

Yes, this is the most promising possibility I've read yet. A fight to the death between Roderick and Joe. And, then, for good measure, Emma & Louise get to go at it: fight to the death. For all of The Followers' ecstatic joy!

This is, bar none, the most hilarious show on TV today. I keep wondering what the writers/producers/Fox TV are trying for here, and IT GOT RENEWED! Is there any way to watch this show other than as one hilarious gag after another? I also love these recaps/reviews & comments, makes me feel like we're in our own special…