Match Point?
Did anyone discuss Match point for this list? The twist in that one certainly caught me off guard.

Spore
If there were a list of Top 10 Most Disappointing Games of 2008, Spore would take up spots 1-10 in my book. After all the hype, the game just didn't fully flesh out any of its segments of evolution, leaving me feeling as if I didn't have the opportunity to enjoy any one segment of a "level."

Fallout 3?
I'm confused - is this a ranked list or just individual critics picks for for their favorite game? If it is ranked, I find it hard to argue Left 4 Dead did more to advance the genre than Fallout 3 did. Sure, Left 4 Dead is a great exploration of cooperative multiplayer, but at its core the game is just a…