Not entirely true. Australia was the season where the producers had to bail out the contestants because they weren't getting enough food, and then their camp was washed away in a flash flood. And australia is almost universally considered one of the best seasons, myself included

I didn't discover av club til this year so I cannot wait to discuss this season and not just read other peoples comments. A quick look back at the episodes showed that, by my count, there's three transcendent episodes, two fantastic episodes, and no duds, even by AD standards, in the first 7-8 episodes. And that's…

I didn't discover av club til this year so I cannot wait to discuss this season and not just read other peoples comments. A quick look back at the episodes showed that, by my count, there's three transcendent episodes, two fantastic episodes, and no duds, even by AD standards, in the first 7-8 episodes. And that's…

Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition!

Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition!

Hey, give a little love for season 3, yes it's not quite as good as the first two seasons, but it's still brilliant, and the British arc is criminally underrated, I think it was one of the best creative ideas the show ever had, though I know many of you would disagree

Hey, give a little love for season 3, yes it's not quite as good as the first two seasons, but it's still brilliant, and the British arc is criminally underrated, I think it was one of the best creative ideas the show ever had, though I know many of you would disagree

Yeah that's always the impression I got. He married jeyne because it was the honorable thing to do

Yeah that's always the impression I got. He married jeyne because it was the honorable thing to do

Amen

Agreed, I really think people are underselling this season. It was especially good compared to the snoopers of the last few years

Seconded

Yeah I thought everyone knew that Chelsea's was so far up Kim's ass that she wouldn't get any bitterness votes, plus I always got the vibe that she really wasn't popular in camp

The stupidity of the cast on is season is nothing compared to redemption island. After Boston rob, the next smartest player strategically was probably……..Dave? First jury member with a ridiculously overinflated ego who did jack squat? Troyzan, Chelsea, Sabrina, Jonas,ll maybe even jay or Alicia were better than him.…

I liked china. Todd was a deserving, if sometimes annoying, winner, there was some great characters like James and Courtney, the great moment where James got blindsided with two idols, and Amanda jacked up the hotness level of the season significantly. Winning all around

Man now I'm totally psyched for that idea. Someone call CBS and lets make this happen for season 30.

Fourth actually, after marquesas, all stars, and HvV. Still, he so singlehandedly dominated that season, I think the bigger asterisk is that he was playing with a bunch of complete idiots

If you're referring to Nina I believe the reason her face looked so bad on the show is that she whacked it during the first challenge. Just bad luck for her all around.

Have to agree about Nicaragua. I was actively rooting for Fabio to win, which in retrospect definitely points to a bad season. Even Fiji had yau-man and that great tribal where dreamz flipped and edgardo got blindsided.

Question- since she's won, where does Kim rank among the all time survivor winners? I'd put her in the same ballpark as yul or parvati, below Richard hatch and Boston rob. Definitely top 10, borderline top 5