Having watched (and finished) the fourth season, I can tell you that they did not miscast her. I understand your trepidation but she proves her worth throughout. Didn't really know she could act lol.

Not emmy worthy, but definitely a great Anthony Anderson peformance.

Myles, I wish I could share your romanticised view of grading but I am realistic. People read reviews, new viewers read reviews. Your grading go towards an aggregate score on websites like rotten tomatoes and metacritic, right? How you rate a TV show and how someone explores that TV show goes hand in hand. People have…

How does that explain last week's grade? Overwhelming positive response and still a B-? That can't be justified even when taking in "different perspectives"

WHAT THE HELL IS WITH THIS REVIEWER?! This has to be some of the best television on the air at the moment and yet, only a B? SMH

I know the emmy's have a bias opinion about Procedurals but where the hell is JLM nominations? The emmy needs to take the carrot out of it's a$$

Yes, that episode was an A-, that last scene was breathtaking and the teenage actress (maybe not a teenager) was stellar!

"Imagine for one depressing moment" and "I could always use friends in middle places" JLM delivers shade so perfectly it's almost flawless. Also, is this the first A- this reviewer has given out for 'Elementary'?

This was an 'A' episode, why the hell was it rated B-?