I remember reading somewhere on the interwebs a similar discussion about that line, and how Lauren Graham didn't even want to say it because she thought it was out of character

I'm still holding out for that to become a season-long arc, one person steps in the electrocution puddle each episode

*Hears glass shatter* You know, somehow I've never thought of this and I've seen this episode many times.

I always assumed that Lorelai was gone for more than 10 minutes but was trying to sneak her way back in anyway

I definitely had AYAOTD-related nightmares as a kid, but for some reason the only episode that I can really remember is the Melissa Joan Hart episode where the conflict was that the scary ghost………. was cold.

I remember watching that one and as a kid thinking "Holy crap! Kids' shows never have unhappy endings!"

I always assumed the same, but even still it seemed odd to spend so much time on someone who is never even mentioned again

I think it's fair to say that Sims is trolling us at this point. Giving us the teaser already that he hates next week's episodes too is the kicker

I'm fairly certain the whole #EzrA thing was a misdirect and that first part of your comment is exactly how they're going to explain it away next season. We didn't see Ezra actually do anything bad, just get angry.

Every time I watch this episode, it strikes me that Rory gets all dressed up to see Jess at the end of summer festival, but then she picks THOSE SHOES. I remember thinking they were hideous even back when it first aired

You'd think he and Martial Arts Jake would at least be friends

Same here. That has to be what they're doing. The real question is: why can't they send Toby to Ravenswood instead?

Is anyone but me wondering what happened to New Detective Handsome? If we're going to waste time on new characters, I'd rather it be that one.

For some reason, that little bit is one of my favorites in the show's entire run.

She did, and Pennsatucky was religious and a meth addict, but she and Piper were friends. It's one of the ways the book story differs from the show, which is nice because you can enjoy both things without one spoiling the other

I imagine she would get crazy stoned, listen to "Bangin on a Trash Can"
and then get really paranoid from the "So many voices calling me,
calling me" part

It definitely should be Pennsyltucky, but in the book, Kerman spells it as Pennsatucky, so that's how it's listed in the credits. But the meaning is the same

At this point I just assume the wardrobe director is trolling us all

My roommates and I reacted the same way to the bird comment, that almost made putting up with Toby all this time worth it

It seems pretty far-fetched to me that Emily falling on a rock leads to a partially torn rotator cuff. Especially when she seems to be in no pain at all when she's going about her daily activities.