"GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAK!" is right. Madonna's recorded some great music since 1992—not the least of which is Music.

"GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAK!" is right. Madonna's recorded some great music since 1992—not the least of which is Music.

southparkstudios.com

I disagree with that too, but it's just his opinion. And it's not unheard of: I think in "You're Getting Old" the humor was secondary. More than it was funny, that was episode was super affecting.

Come on, AV Club, you're better than the guys at IGN. Stop bashing the reviewer. 

I like your avatar.

I guess I'm lucky to like Matt and Trey as dudes. Even though I don't think South Park performs at its Seasons 4-9 level anymore, I still like almost every episode and appreciate the humor over the stuff that falls flat (MOST of the time). It's sweet that South Park didn't end—I'm liking this season a lot.

Plus a great director. But yeah, gotta be the catchiest South Park song since "Brian Boitano"—at least that I can remember.

You mean the one-shot thing? That video is awesome.

Man, I thought the bulk of this episode deserved an A. It felt like a classic the whole time. But then that ending… well, it happened. What did you guys think of the ending? Anyone got anything convincingly good to say about it? I really want to love this episode.

Yeah. Not sure about 20 seasons. The last four have been entertaining but weak overall. With five more, they could either work hard to regain their sturdy footing in Seasons 3-10, or they could just be refusing the show a chance to die with dignity. I'll watch whatever happens, but maybe not happily.