I've voted one evening so far this season. That was for Siobahn about 4 weeks ago. I've hated every performance of hers (her's?) since that night and I want her gone.

High or stupid Mr. Tusks—only way you could consider this a great episode. Literally. Not. One. Laugh.

psst…it's MacFarlane

Bad acne and products intended to attack and conceal said acne.

I'm not getting the split on Siobahn's performance. She was easily my favorite leading into last week, but with two complete stinkers in a row I won't be sad to see her go at all. There was nothing the least bit entertaining about her performance last night. AI is not about subtle nuance.

Yes, as I tweeted to Claire (c'mon Claire, validate me) it was his first performance that moved me. Actually it was Crystal's first me-moving performance as well. Maybe I'm just drunker'n usual.

Eh, I've seen Scarface, but unless you're a douche that has watched it over and over again (or very recently), last night's references could've been to any generic gangster movie.

T&E reviews always turned into 80% commenters ridiculing those of us that love the show. I'm fine with them ending those reviews. Not sure why the abandoned the Sarah Silverman reviews after one episode this season…

How else would one pronounce Inez? Certainly not eenez…

Instant classic
That's right. Instant classic.

I'm with you Pilot. Funniest episode for me in quite some time.

Dollars to donuts next season is the last.

Don't disagree. You're right, getting Miley to sign her geetar was quite calculating.

Amen on both points.

Siobahn was my favorite going into tonight. I'd like to punch her square in the kisser right about now.

I just watched Didi perform. I obviously know nothing about music, because I expected rave reviews…was my fave performance so far tonight. I suck at hearing I guess.

Power of Love
Kara is such a tard. How exactly was that note for note remake of a shitty song "current?"

Fidel, I had to look that up. It's actually C., none of the above. It's waling:

Well I am someone sitting alone at a computer at 10:10 on a thursday night talking about american idol…

No, ICR, Paige is terrible and has been from the beginning. I can't believe she got through and I blame votefortheworst.