She was pretty much bawling about the Lilly booting. Think you guys were misreading her.

BULL
SHIT

Spot on review Claire
I give you an A.

Paige does have votefortheworst.com in her corner, but then again so did Haeley…

Leonard, that bit of knowledge says more about you than the non-Simon judges.

Wait, seriously Claire?

Ditto. I saw it on my dvr schedule so assumed it was new…happened to be one of a few series I forgot to have only new eps be recorded.

Am I alone in thinking Krasinski is probably very girthy? Something about that nose. Yeah, I'm probably still drunk.

The girls seem pretty bonded already. A lot of very genuine looking tears at both "evictions." Many looked completely stunned at Michelle getting the boot. Did they not go back and watch? She may be a fine singer, but her performance was by far my least favorite last night—the judges bullshit couldn't save that…

I fastforwarded all of Gokey. Even watching it that way I thought to myself…wtfuck is that guy on?

@Luke, I'm not your father. I agree—I've thought for some time now he's one of the best written and acted kids on tv today. Though it doesn't get a lot of love on here, the kids on In the Middle are all pretty great, in a much more over the top way.

The only perfomance I'd pay to download so far was Alex Lambert's from Tuesday.

I'm pretty sure it's a condition. As in, he has the gay or, he caught the gay whilst watching American Idol.

But it seems like you were addressing Americans, so I was responding as an American. What made me think you were addressing Americans…

Cmon, dude's only 16—still maturing etc. But as long as we're being mean, he needs to do something about that nose.

I was specifically talking about women's hockey. Really, I can't imagine anyone in the US cares about it except for MAYBE some of the players' family members. More generally, I don't care about the winter olympics at all, but I know there are a few kooks out there that do. Carry on.

No one cares Fidel.

Dialidol says Andrew Garcia and Katie Stevens are the only 2 that are safe tonight. Bowersox and Casey James show up as 2nd in their respective categories, but the margin of error is such that neither of them are considered safe from going home tonight.

The only other Siobahn I've ever even heard of is the transexual wack packer on Howard Stern.

Agreed, ICR, and she was one of, if not the only chick I was looking forward to hearing. Really terrible.