They even lampshaded this in the episode with Cartman talking about how his prank was the best thing ever and either Kyle or Stan saying 'eh, seems pretty typical.'

Wait what league is this that is 'way beyond' a ripped billionaire superhero?

This episode was hilarious - I was shocked to see a C+. To echo what seems to be the consensus:

Just say 'next one's coming faster', afterwards. No one will realize your mistake.

It's like he's playing checkers and they're playing that game where you slap each other in the face until someone quits.