Indian pudding
None of you have even heard of Indian pudding? Whoa, regional bias. You need to get yourselves some New England writers.

Really? I mean I like that song a lot too, but then you must really, really like the lyrics. I say that because, as such an authority on the subject, I'm sure you know that they jacked the beat from an old Project Pat joint.

Correction
Rick Ross' album is called "Trilla." Bun B's album is called "II Trill."

Unless I'm wrong and the name is a coincidence, in which case, don't get creeped out.

Hey, I think I know you. And if I'm right, you don't really play bass that much anymore.

Grateful Dead
I strongly disagree that Jerry Garcia wasn't a good singer. And the Dead aren't known for their harmonies? Have you ever listened to American Beauty, or Workingman's Dead, or any of Europe 72?

David— first of all, relax.

You're right about the difference between science and religion. And to me, the thinking behind religion, as you described it, is a problem. It's cheap, it's lazy, and the conclusion that it yields is most likely completely wrong. The religious notion that it all comes down to faith, and that's where the argument, by…

They wanted to draft L. Ron out of high school too, but he decided to go to college. Then he blew out his knee and was told he could never play again. He got so mad, he started a global cult/pyramid scheme so the world could feel his pain.

How does that explain it? Creationism isn't really part of that theory at all. And his points about human spiritual uniqueness are flawed and not fully explored. Humans are moral because morality is an evolutionary advantage. Cooperating with fellow humans and protecting weak members of the species is more likely to…

Lewis— how are evolution and creation not mutually exclusive? To me, they seem completely mutually exclusive. And yeah, I've seen "Inherit the Wind." That ain't gonna cut it.

They filmed Rumble in the Bronx in Vancouver too.

Fair enough; no hostility intended. I have a pretty knee-jerk, pissed off defensive reaction to any rap hate on these boards. Generally, I get a very racist vibe from those comments, and the people making them usually seem to have no idea what they're talking about. It drives me crazy how a demographic that tends to…

Jesus, I was just going to comment how happy I was that such a rap-heavy list hadn't generated an ignorant fucking thread as this. I was so proud of the AV Club commenters for once. I knew it was too good to be true.

Beatles: The kid Sophie chooses

It absolutely is a rock and roll album. Every song. And Ghost is dead on (get it?).

"Beatles = MLK, Stones = Malcolm X" is one of the greatest analogies I've ever heard, whether you intended it or not.

Haha, thanks Sean. I wasn't looking for personal recognition, however; just making sure you didn't attribute the humor of "What What" to South Park instead of Samwell, to whom the credit is truly due. Anyway, I gotta go; I'm doing a double funnel of mead and this chick is rending her bodice to me.

AV Club? Any recognition of What What in the Butt being an existing youtube thing, not an original song?

What What in the Butt already exists. It's another one of those youtube videos; that's how it tied in with Chocolate Rain, etc. Come on, AV Club, I thought you had pop culture on lock.