When my 6th grade English class had a Hobbit party (yes, I realize how much that might explain about me), lembas bread was definitely shortbread, with different types of jam. That's how I will always imagine it.

The gator 'jammies were the best sight gag.

Leslie getting all discomfited when Ben insisted she take his name just tore me up. It was perfect and I loved it.

Ugh, I hate how "Moffat-y" is an insult now, and a completely valid one at that. He did so much for the show, but seems set on undoing even more.

This was Luke Perry's week for guest starring! So surreal after his cameo on Raising Hope

@avclub-4acd793a645f227d84ddb7c4c3f16603:disqus But strangely couldn't save Ghost Whisperer

@avclub-f9612d06549ffe449e39e34fae8e2549:disqus Again, right behind Sherlock.

I can't tell if it's cruel or brilliant that she is clearly not fully in on the joke.

I thought this episode was Tan-amazing!

Ha, and I lived in SF and was dating a Giants fan while I was there.

But when will we get Bill Murray??

You should become a Dodger fan out of spite.

"slips on" is confusing in this context.

I do! It remains in my top-5 shows ever. Last summer I saw Tanya Franks
in a coffee shop and I think she thought I was a mental patient because I
tried to talk to her about how much I love Pulling and no words came
out so I tried to play it off like I was just really confused and turned
and walked away, but left my…

@avclub-94d8526a5fae933806f65b8a0f49301a:disqus Whatever, they had GREAT chemistry.

Todd gave us an excuse to talk about baseball!! Is anyone going to Spring Training this year?

I'm a subscriber to the "Shelby is Drew Thompson" theory. Arlo's reaction tonight only furthered my belief.

YES. TIM. Relatedly: the best Valentine I got was Tim-themed. I wish I could post photos here, but it just said "I'm a deputy US Marshal and I'm officially requisitioning your heart". It was perfect.

Great name. Too bad she was super boring. I swear, Timothy Olyphant could have chemistry with 99% of all women. Why'd they cast someone in that one percent?

I feel ya. I am constantly shocked at how well this show reflects my own 20-something experience. Like, are the writers Truman Show-ing me? Is that how they understand so well? Or, alternatively, am I really just the same as everyone else?