Yes, the pie makes sense but then it turns into a mass poisoning. Who gains from that? Little finger? The Starks?

My own take on the poisoning was that it wasn't intended for joffrey but Margaery. It looked to me like Joffrey was finished with his cup and needed another. Tyrion looked like he grabbed the cup in front of her, not Joffrey. And who would want to poison Margaery? Only Cersei probably. So . . .delicious irony to boot?…

Lord Grantham: "Mary, there's this letter that clearly states Matthew wants to leave you everything but I don't want it to be legal because I want everything and also the intentions stated aren't clear. I still love you very much"
Mary: "Oh"
Lord Grantham: "It turns out the letter is legitimate and you get half. Now I'm…

2 lovers, both dead. Season 5 is going to tie in with Sherlock Holmes

Lord Grantham is the best thing of the series now. I can't wait to see what wacky ideas he comes up with. "Let's sell all this money-making land to pay a tax instead of taking out a low-interest loan" "Let's invest all our money in horse-drawn carriages" "The future of our estate is in the production and sale of…

@ SG Standard I don't think the writers are doing a bad job, I just think it was a relatively big reveal that a lot of people (and reviewers) might not have caught. None of the characters except Theon could or should know about it right now, although maybe Maester Luwin  since he must have seen who actually burned…

Agree, this was a very key plot point that just whisked right by in one line. Oh, the iron islanders left and winterfell was burning when we got there . . .so either roose bolton's bastard is lying to everyone, or he is acting under bolton's orders and bolton is lying to everyone. Either way, somebody is working…

2 season marathon of "The Killing"