I binged it all on Netflix in a weekend and it was great. I especially loved the onomatopoeia episode titles because they made guessing the murders more fun. I also have a huge Katie Cassidy crush so that was fun.

I'm choosing to believe she just pregamed her wedding hard.

It rewrote Arrow so S3 never happened except for Thea and Laurel 's development and Diggle and Lyla's wedding. And Nyssa joined Team Arrow full time.

A musical episode! Better than Once More With Feeling!

I lost it multiple times this episode but Barry calling Joe dad was the hardest moment and it was beautiful.

Eddie >>>>> Whitney. Also, I've enjoyed one season of the Flash more than all of Smallville combined.

I'd be down for watching Drunk Iris if she hangs out with Drunk Caitlin.

No, @avclub-453ef031bde3e96ab264269b9eb3c7c4:disqus is from the future where he downloaded all the Legends episodes. What a jerk face.

I'm impressed we got a song that wasn't "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" or "The Rains of Castamere." Actual world-building, who knew?

So how does Olyvar actually prove that Margaery knew about Loras sleeping with men? He could have claimed that anybody walked into that room.

The rooftop scene was 3 days after the the box and tunnel scene. We don't know when Joan and the others found Sherlock (could be the first day or the third day) but she clearly was trying to support him and help him out as a friend through this period.

My vote is for Charles Dance but I'm sure they'll go with someone lesser known who will still be fantastic.

Thank you for the many incredible reviews Myles. It isn't easy to analyze a more procedural show like Elementary (quite possibly the most procedural show with regular reviews here), yet every week you give detailed, meaningful thoughts on the show. We'll miss your reviews as much as we miss Joan's wardrobe and Clyde's…

4. It achieved in 6 minutes what took Smallville 10 whole seasons to do: have the main character FLY.

He should just cut off his hand to stop the spread of greyscale. Then he and Jaime can bond over romantic problems with troubled blonde queens and learning how to fight one-handed.

She's just pre-gaming for when Lady Olenna comes back because that's when it's on for real.

It really is the dumbest thing to lock in an actor for a series regular contract, then ignore his entire previous story with Ana and STILL have him do basically nothing for his entire time on this show. Get it together, OUAT, and bring back Mulan!

You would think that, and yet we rarely get the Felicity and Laurel scenes that could at least be pretty different for both characters.

They're both happy Iris knows now because they'll give her all the inmate chores - "You said you wanted to help out!"

That's a season finale level of revelations right there.