Actually I think it earns a C. Definitely not above a B-. The show is very very close to jumping the shark (drawing out these flashbacks when we really don't care - or at least I don't). And that courtroom "drama"? The corniest thing this show has ever done since we had the first murder case way back in season 1…

This was one of the worst episodes, honestly. Confusing as hell, barely advanced the plot, half the episode may have been a hallucination. Definitely not the kind of episode that should kick off post-hiatus.