Growing up in San Fran in the 80's, I was a HUGE HLATN fan. Not so much now, my tastes have matured. You shouldn't feel bad for what you liked as a teenager. My neice (14) loves American Idol. No problem. That people my age love it…

MY ADDITION
One that I haven't seen mentioned in any of the comments is The Pledge. Beautiful scenery, intriguing story, great acting, and hatefully soul-crushing.