Why me? He's not contradicting anything I asserted in the review.

Just so we're clear: So long as you criticize the show and not the people who like it, you can post away and not be deleted. Your initial post was pretty close to that line, as have some of your other posts in this thread. Please don't be rude or insulting to the other commenters.

Just so we're clear: So long as you criticize the show and not the people who like it, you can post away and not be deleted. Your initial post was pretty close to that line, as have some of your other posts in this thread. Please don't be rude or insulting to the other commenters.

It's not running today.

It's not running today.

You're disagreeing only with my wording it seems. Our interpretation appears to be exactly the same. I reiterate: I remembered the scene, and described it as I meant to. I know this because I actually did think about how best to phrase it, given how the power shifts throughout. Apologies if you disagree with that…

You're disagreeing only with my wording it seems. Our interpretation appears to be exactly the same. I reiterate: I remembered the scene, and described it as I meant to. I know this because I actually did think about how best to phrase it, given how the power shifts throughout. Apologies if you disagree with that…

No, I remembered it right. That's why I very carefully used the words "lets him know" and not "says." They're playing out a dynamic where he's calling her what he thinks of himself, and she plays that part for him, until she flips it.

No, I remembered it right. That's why I very carefully used the words "lets him know" and not "says." They're playing out a dynamic where he's calling her what he thinks of himself, and she plays that part for him, until she flips it.

That line may have been a bit much. I questioned myself on that. But I do try to keep it fun.

That line may have been a bit much. I questioned myself on that. But I do try to keep it fun.

Thanks right back! (Though to be fair, I'm 85% certain that my read on the meaning of Harrow is just in my own head and not something the writers intended, at least based on my post-S2 conversation with Terence WInter. Doesn't mean it's not still a cool motif, though … just maybe one that's deeply embedded in the show…

Thanks right back! (Though to be fair, I'm 85% certain that my read on the meaning of Harrow is just in my own head and not something the writers intended, at least based on my post-S2 conversation with Terence WInter. Doesn't mean it's not still a cool motif, though … just maybe one that's deeply embedded in the show…

You're welcome!

You're welcome!

She was much, much better this season than she was in S2, when she had a strangely mannered style of delivering all the old-timey dialogue.

She was much, much better this season than she was in S2, when she had a strangely mannered style of delivering all the old-timey dialogue.

It's a line from the movie.

It's a line from the movie.

The 40th anniversary edition is a box set with the entire paper replicated in booklet form.