Yeah but Hand of Fate was such a good episode, how can you complain?

LOST
It's less a "wish I could erase my memory of it and do it again on DVD" wanting-to-do-it-for-the-first-time-again for me and more a "wish I could go back in time, inhabit the body of my younger self and experience the show all over again week by week".

I've seen Rushmore something like ten times now, but yeah, that's definitely a "wish I could do that again" experience.

I think Children of Men and Brick were both movies I enjoyed more on the second go through, and I didn't really pay attention during the last part of TWBB so I'm gonna have to watch that again.

No, Adventureland is this week and O&R is next week I think.

Haven't seen it yet.
I think I was 3 or 4 when ER first started so it has been a show that has always been on TV for me, and a show I assumed would always be on TV, like a medical version of Law and Order.

It's sad
that the review for the series finale has more comments than pretty much any review for any episode of the show.

Like I said, there is no evidence that Ben is unstuck from time. I'm not completely ruling it out, but being unstuck is what makes Des "special", so until we have proof that both Locke and Ben are unstuck in some way (minus the Island time hops) I'm gonna go with "what happened happened."

As far as we've seen no. There has been no evidence that what applies to Desmond applies to Ben or anyone else, because DESMOND IS SPECIAL. His unstuck-ness was caused by the Hatch explosion.

That only happened, though, because Desmond is unstuck from time.

You are thinking too linear, Schiels.

Although in Brick you don't really know she's pregnant until almost the end.

Ah ok, that works.

He just stares at Ben and Ben asks "Where's Alex?" and Locke says "Alex is dead, Ben." and Ben just screams "NOOOOOOOOOOOOO"

But Ben TOLD Jack they had to bring Locke back. And I assumed he meant the last thing he remembered was dying.

At least we can say one thing.
Between the mediocre ending of BSG and this ludicrously hilarious ending, the ER series finale could be the hospital exploding and it would still be great.

"Whatever the Case May Be" was always my favorite because it had the best title.

I'm sure they are going to kill a character or put that character in a situation of peril by the finale because that's the LOST way, but I doubt that Ben will die so soon before the actual series finale, considering that the whole plot has become about his past and its relation to everyone else's future.

But the thing is, we actually didn't know what went down in that scenario. Nothing was PREDICTED except that they couldn't change the past, no one knew Ben got shot as a kid in the past. Yes, we know that Ben survives but we don't know how.

It's an April Fool's joke.