I used to be a huge fan, but the show just turned into a grim, repetitive, self-indulgent morass in the last two seasons. Kudos to them for a consistency entertaining show, but I think overall it could have ended at year 4 or 5.

Love the new show. I'll take KO, warts and all.

It's a damn good show, end of story.

This show stinks. I'm out.

Dodee is the new Hurley. In other news, this show's writers are excruciatingly bad. How can a show with eight executive producers be this bad? "Under the Dumb" is more like it.

I love watching Sackhoff act. I'm reading the books, and she's nailing the Vic character—at least with what she is given by the show's writers. It's a good show; it could be great. I will be watching to see if that happens.