avclub-570e72724ec4b76760248ccdae0449f8--disqus
Welcome to the Thunderdome
avclub-570e72724ec4b76760248ccdae0449f8--disqus

Don't forget Brooklyn Decker.

Don't forget Brooklyn Decker.

That was horrible. I love her.

That was horrible. I love her.

This is absurd. Have we been watching the same show, or at least the same past four seasons?

This is absurd. Have we been watching the same show, or at least the same past four seasons?

You are the only person in the world who likes Ted more than Barney.

You are the only person in the world who likes Ted more than Barney.

Yes, that's why I said only the Season 4 finale really introduces the next season. None of the other season finales do.

Yes, that's why I said only the Season 4 finale really introduces the next season. None of the other season finales do.

(BUFFY SPOILERS) Sure, the sacrifice aspect. But not the Glory/God aspect.

(BUFFY SPOILERS) Sure, the sacrifice aspect. But not the Glory/God aspect.

That trend is not a trend. It only applies to Season 4, as though Joss Whedon knew how awful The Initiative had turned out and decided to make a treat for fans. It definitely does not apply to Seasons 1, 3, 5 and 6, though there is a vague reference to the Season 3 Big Bad in the Season 2 finale.

That trend is not a trend. It only applies to Season 4, as though Joss Whedon knew how awful The Initiative had turned out and decided to make a treat for fans. It definitely does not apply to Seasons 1, 3, 5 and 6, though there is a vague reference to the Season 3 Big Bad in the Season 2 finale.

Season 5 is wonderful. Season 6 is good but very gloomy. Season 7 has a lot of strong episodes but is a little disjointed.

Season 5 is wonderful. Season 6 is good but very gloomy. Season 7 has a lot of strong episodes but is a little disjointed.

For me, top five with "Once More With Feeling," "The Zeppo" and "Dopplegangland." To me, "The Gift" would be wasted on someone who didn't watch all or most of Season 5.

For me, top five with "Once More With Feeling," "The Zeppo" and "Dopplegangland." To me, "The Gift" would be wasted on someone who didn't watch all or most of Season 5.

Season 6 WAS NOT WEAK.

Season 6 WAS NOT WEAK.