100 per cent true

By far the worst episode of the series. Just unrelentingly horrible from start to finish. Oh, I forgot, the episode grades for this reviewer specifically depend on Chad Radwell's involvement/Chanel being made fun of. Okay, good writing 👍 Or not.

Doesn't change the fact that it was the worst episode.

It was, by far, the worst episode of the season. Once again baffled by the episode's grade but, hey, that's the norm for this reviewer.

I can't believe this was even an AHS episode. It was amazing from start to finish. And I take back anything bad I ever said about Gaga, she's amazing as well. I never thought I'd say that…

Great review, and I totally agree about the camera work during tribal council. Also, Stephen and Jeremy were just so intense with their facial expressions, it was epic.

Don't trust the grades(for either show), they don't even match the written reviews the recapper provides for AHS. This is easily the worst season ever. SQ is actually better, shockingly enough :p

This

Baffled by the episode grade, this was easily the best episode yet and deserved at least a B+ (preferably an A- or A).

Can we get a new reviewer? Seriously? This was probably the dumbest AHS episode ever.. One of the worst… And it's got one of the highest episode grades ever? Ridiculous!,

Me too. This season of AHS is just the worst, and Gaga is insufferable.

I'm baffled when I see anyone praise Gaga's acting. Each time she speaks, my friends and I unintentionally burst out laughing. Sure, she can stand around and gaze, as any pop star can do in a music video, but when she has to speak she's simply terrible. Don't get me started on when she tries to envoke any emotion…. So…

lol k

Yup, totally accurate comment, totally agree. You can pretty much count on this reviewer to be consistently wrong about this show each week.

Yeah, the last few episodes were definitely better than this one. Definitely a huge let-down.

This episode was totally amazing!!! Really losing faith in AV Club when a reviewer bashes episodes like this but gives positive reviews to… Other certain shows. Such a crock of shit, really making a bad name for the site…