Hey, stereotypically sarcastic A.V. Club commenter, way to follow the snarky hipster herd. You're so edgy.

I appreciate Theodore as well, but really do think Justin took a step up with his songwriting for Water Liars. I can't wait to see how they evolve!

If you look at the photo on Water Liars' sites, it appears they are in a photo booth with their shirts off, smoking cigarettes. Viewing it in full, I think it was designed to look more comical than antiquated, though I clearly see how you got a different impression. That boy can sing.