Eh, I thought she was a low part of season 8 as well.

That's easily the best episode of the show.

Did the remastered DuckTales game do well? If so, then yes, probably.

I actually thought that the locket was going to wash upon the shore at the end of the episode.

"I like Halloween! Eez nice!"
"Eez also tomorrow."
"Dammit!"

They're… eh. The first handful of episodes of season 8 are easily among the show's worst.

…besides that.

If you notice, Barney didn't make or have the guys make one derogatory move at all in the episode, unless you count the strip club, which I totally don't.

Season 5, the year everything got resolved in 5 episodes or less.

Besides Zoey, everything else was on point. Marshall, Barney and Robin had some of their best storyarcs, and the episodes without her rank among the best.

I'm able to forgive Zoey, partly since the rest of the material that year was strong enough to make up for her, but mostly because of the Captain.

Have you missed the episodes with the mother?

But it really is Jeanette.

That's ultimately true, but also consider that it's hard to completely get over someone. While Robin has all but decided on Barney being the one she wants to spend her life with, I can still see an ever-so-slight love for Ted in her.

The thing is, I do think that Robin loves Ted as well, but they just aren't aligned to be together in this world. Maybe in another lifetime, they could be.

I love how Robin is both over-confident and critical of herself at the same time. There's no way she'd consider herself for either list.

She was totally on the bottom 5 list

Robin should always be #1, honestly.

Maybe she already is dead, and the whole past couple of years have just been made up in Ted's mind

We have like 7 episodes yet. Even though "P.S., I Love You" is the last Robin Sparkles episode for sure, don't count anything else out.