While I agree that it was a great episode overall, and Adam McKay was a FANTASTIC guest, I was a little put off by Matt's "Atheist Rant" rant. I'd agree with him that I'd never heard him do anything that could be described that way before, but in responding he actually kind of legitimized the criticism for me. When he…

While I agree that it was a great episode overall, and Adam McKay was a FANTASTIC guest, I was a little put off by Matt's "Atheist Rant" rant. I'd agree with him that I'd never heard him do anything that could be described that way before, but in responding he actually kind of legitimized the criticism for me. When he…

don't forget people with existing medical conditions who would have just died after their year's worth of supplies ran out. thanks adama, I need insulin to live but I understand that you're afraid it'll evolve into a robot, so I'll just going into shock and die in a cave.

also I agree with Colby. I don't think I was alone or especially clever in predicting early on in the series that it was all taking place in our ancient history, and DREADING that possibility, only to be relieved when the star map to old earth showed our constellations. I was happy that they weren't taking that route,…

I always wondered how the rest of humanity felt about adama and roslin making that decision unilaterally for the rest of them. especially those who were infirm or even disabled. we keep killing ourselves by building robots, better abandon medical technology and agriculture. so what if a few people die or starve to…