Alec seems to have some pretty deep seated issues about his versus Drew's treatment in their family. His non-sensical projection of all of his Drew shit onto Baylor was yet another highlight of the episode.

I don't think that Keith even dislikes him. I think Keith just does not understand how idols function within an alliance; his reaction to the concept of a "sub-alliance" was priceless.

The problem I had was the huge assumption JT made that this was the only possible scenario. You never would have seen Boston Rob, Parvarti or Sandra make a mistake like that. I contend that JT won his season because he was a Magic Man who was beloved by those playing with him to an irrational degree. HvV proved to me…

http://www.people.com/artic…

If I can I'd like to swap out Val for Reed, if that four isn't available I'll stick with my initial pick.

If no one has chosen this foursome yet I want: Alek, Josh, Val, and Jeremy. Thank you, Judge!

Utterly fantastic! Kudos, John Teti.

I was excited when they indicated that the older woman demographic was going to be represented, but then hearing that you were still in college for the early seasons I was depressed to realize that I am a whole different level of old.

I find Phillip nearly intolerable to watch, but as others stated people who were on the island with him seem to have some level of affection for him. Kass doesn't bug me to watch, but clearly everyone who had to live with her was doing everything they could not to completely lose their shit on her every single day. I…

But if Tony talks from the heart about how much it hurt him to take out his most trusted allies (as was shown in one of the extra scenes on-line) the authenticity will off set the lack of calm. Maybe it's just because I'm from Jersey, but when Tony expresses his emotions, like when he declared his love for the…

There was only one vote for Kass, they always show the votes in a way to maximize drama, so if anyone other than Trish had voted for Kass that vote would have been revealed.

We have to do way too much speculating because the edit gave us nothing about Tony's reasoning, but we do know that in terms of the TP idol Tony was planning to trick everyone into believing that it was good through final four and that to do that he needed to hang onto the idol. By voting out Trish along with Woo he…

Damn you, Saturday Night Palsy!

I think the key to Woo's thinking is that he described the idea of going to Final Tribal with Tony as "a beautiful thing" because they had been together from the beginning. Woo is not thinking of who he can beat, he is thinking about loyalty and that is why he was so shocked when Kass told him that Tony swore on his…

Upvoted based on a blanket policy of up voting any comment which includes "Fuck You, Probst."

I think Tony believed that it was the only way he could prove to Woo that he was in Tony's final three.

Bestie, he voted her out!

But Stephen also said that in this case he thought production might keep it a secret.

I continue to have a major problem with the TP idol beyond my early season misgivings about a super powered idol. Since Tony is the only player who knows how the idol works it seems like an obscene advantage to not only give one player a tool that powerful, but to also not give everyone else a solid understanding of…

Production leaving the viewers completely in the dark with no indictaion that Tony might possibly vote for Trish felt like a cheap ploy to shock us. That is some bullshit editing shenanigans that the episode did not need to be interesting.