Just going by the last 2 weeks, I think Jasmine and Amy should win. Since there will be a girl and guy winner, I think Amy and Fikshun should win.

I'm with you too. I rewatched the dance twice, each time focusing on one person and  then the other and I think Marko was much tighter and with better (facial) expressions. Not to take anything away from Jasmine. She grabbed the attention.

Wow! Acting and dancing — superb. So much personality. Thanks for sharing.

Nigel just revealed that the cumulative votes for Amy/Fik-Shun far outstrips every other couple. They ARE the couple to beat.

That tango dude was sick. He oozed command and masculinity. That brought out the tango dancer in Hayley. The way the two were giggling in the practice clip you would never have gotten the tango we saw tonight. Which again underlines what has been said many times about the maturity of the dancers and the difference…

For me it just doesn't make any sense for the chap to go to all that trouble to find out Marshall's trial strategy and then opt for "swaying the judge and jury with his ass". You want to continue the storyline from last week you should do so properly. Otherwise it is just lazy writing.

For me it just doesn't make any sense for the chap to go to all that trouble to find out Marshall's trial strategy and then opt for "swaying the judge and jury with his ass". You want to continue the storyline from last week you should do so properly. Otherwise it is just lazy writing.

Really? A "B"? It felt like an "A" to me. All the dances were enjoyable and some of the new routines were great. Dragon House was fantastic. (I thought the "best 5 from auditions" was just a way to lead to the Dragon House surprise. The guest singer I sat through because I assume it was part of the deal.) Everyone…

Really? A "B"? It felt like an "A" to me. All the dances were enjoyable and some of the new routines were great. Dragon House was fantastic. (I thought the "best 5 from auditions" was just a way to lead to the Dragon House surprise. The guest singer I sat through because I assume it was part of the deal.) Everyone…

Yup, count me in in loving the jive piece. And I also enjoyed the Eliana's quick step. And I was really hoping to see Allison dance again. Wonderful emoting.

Yup, count me in in loving the jive piece. And I also enjoyed the Eliana's quick step. And I was really hoping to see Allison dance again. Wonderful emoting.

In your words, Eliana is polished, smiling, ballet-dancing, pole-dancing, with gorgeous extensions, precious facial expressions (fake to you), good dancer, picture perfect facial expressions and beautiful extensions but boring.

In your words, Eliana is polished, smiling, ballet-dancing, pole-dancing, with gorgeous extensions, precious facial expressions (fake to you), good dancer, picture perfect facial expressions and beautiful extensions but boring.

+1 to all you wrote. I have always expected a critique from Nigel as a judge. I may not always agree with him but he would often give examples and reasons for his praise or criticism. And on occasions he has not shied away from the difficult responses. I think he does not deserve all the name-calling.

+1 to all you wrote. I have always expected a critique from Nigel as a judge. I may not always agree with him but he would often give examples and reasons for his praise or criticism. And on occasions he has not shied away from the difficult responses. I think he does not deserve all the name-calling.

FWIW I'm with Xora. If an able-bodied dancer did what he did as a guest artist on SYTYCD it would have been embarrassing from an artistic POV.

FWIW I'm with Xora. If an able-bodied dancer did what he did as a guest artist on SYTYCD it would have been embarrassing from an artistic POV.

Someone mentioned Facebook comments so I went for a look. OMG the Cyrus love is almost fanatical. Backlash for sure.

Someone mentioned Facebook comments so I went for a look. OMG the Cyrus love is almost fanatical. Backlash for sure.

I think Nigel was trying to right the wrong. Tonight he clearly said that Eliana and Chehon are the true winners in his eyes although he went on to say that he will accept it if America decides otherwise.