I thought the actress who played Diana looked great and I think it was rude of you to try to be "witty" by mentioning her baby-weight. She didn't look like she recently had a baby- not by a long shot. I think that remark was unnecessary and in poor taste.

No he's not. Peter Hermann is Mariska Hargitay's husband and he played a detective. I was talking about the actor who played Monroe and his name is Ted King.

I wasn't bothered by it because it happens a lot. I noticed that Monroe was familiar too and it took me a few minutes to remember where I knew him from- which, as it happens, was the first season of Charmed when Shannen Doherty was still on and he was her childhood friend/love interest/suspicious police officer.

I disagree with a lot of the review(s) of this episode. I think, just like in life, people all grieve in their own way and this episode demonstrated that very well. I don't think it needs to be considered so much in the larger arc of the series beyond this (i.e. in regards to the timeline) but should rather just be…

Why are you recapping this show if you don't like it and aren't even going to pretend to care? That's disrespectful of the people who take the time to come to this site in search of insightful, thoughtful, and at least moderately accurate reviews. I'm offended by how lazy and uninterested this recap was and I hope…

It wasn't a bad episode but really I watch the show for Sam and Dean and their interactions with each other and the "creature of the week" or whatever- not so much for the one-off characters so I didn't really enjoy it. I liked the parts with Jensen and Jared and everything else just felt like filler to me. It wasn't…

It wasn't a bad episode but really I watch the show for Sam and Dean and their interactions with each other and the "creature of the week" or whatever- not so much for the one-off characters so I didn't really enjoy it. I liked the parts with Jensen and Jared and everything else just felt like filler to me. It wasn't…

Agreed. Clearly the reviewer is not familiar with the name, even having lived through 9/11 and so he missed the point of the joke.

Why are we meant to think that the sheriff is the big bad wolf? Did I miss something?

Ok so I thought actually that it was a pretty good episode. I didn't mind the Quinn twist at the end of the episode because I honestly thought they were doing what they always do on this show and just wipe out a story line suddenly without explanation and Quinn suddenly being back to the girl she was in Season 1…

I'm not worried either. I think this was a great episode actually. I think that returning to the case of the week format was the right thing to do because the characters don't know that anything out of the ordinary has happened yet so they would proceed in that way. And trying to answer all of the questions we as…