I didn't think that was her real voice, either. Josh Dallas and Ginnifer Goodwin are the ones who really came across as having a background in musical theatre (don't know if they do). The green woman was good but I didn't agree with the reviewer that was the best song.

I liked the clips I saw (couldn't watch the show) but why oh why can't gennifer goodwin grow her hair out? That girl is as purely pretty as an infant, but for some reason she's saddled with just about the only haircut she could have that isn't flattering.

Seriously. Who is maraj? Are we supposed to know? And the letters after that — what? It's like one of those scrambled up word games.

Honestly, it surprises me every time Stephen Colbert is vulgar. I don't mind, especially when the target is Trump, but it's a surprise.

Really? You think Once Upon a Time is going full-on Godfather? Interesting.

Well, I don't agree she's "running circles" around her "late-night peers" since the "first episode". I happen to prefer Seth Meyers. Samantha Bee is good but a little of her goes a long way.

Sure — but that's not an obstacle to the original Sherlock, is all I'm saying. That passage of the episode in particular really struck me. The original Sherlock and Watson have a different dynamic.

I don't remember Watson ever out-diagnosing Sherlock. And Sherlock was always reading obscure medical texts and so on. In the books, that would be a perfect moment for Sherlock to demonstrate his astonishing range and Watson to go "Zounds! By Jove, I never heard of such a thing in all my years as a top surgeon.…

That's funny. I was thinking Sherlock had a lot of silent periods in this episode. And the whole scar/carpel tunnel deduction seemed pure Sherlock, at least as he was from the stories.

Yes, I noticed that, too. It started out with this great steampunk, shabby chic feeling, but lately they're letting it deteriorate to something more like a slum, or a squat, for some reason. And it is odd as someone says, since Joan's own apartments were so immaculate, as well as how she dresses.

So beautiful. Very nineteenth century, judging by the brief look I got at it.

"Unaddressed on the show, I figure it has to be mentioned here." Boy, that's pompous. And misguided.

Seriously. I actually loved that. I guess the creepy part is supposed to be how he looks, but his eyes are amazing. He sounds like Matthew McConaghey. So I'm good…

You saw Hamilton?

In this review she takes issue with Shinwell interacting more with Sherlock than Joan, which is like, "he was Joan's friend first", and, so what? It's kind of a subtext humming along in these reviews, that every moment with Sherlock steals one from Joan. Discussion about the intent of the show and other creative…

I think when they come up for a story for her they threaten to go in that direction. Those big emotional moments seem incongruous with the show, and with the actress. I do think that Genevieve is saying she'd rather see less Sherlock altogether, by the way, like he's cramping Joan's style or something.

I think the deadlines are pretty brutal, if they don't get previews. I am surprised they don't go back later and fix them, though.

For me, it's their relationship that I like, so when Joan has a story line that expands that relationship, I'm fine with it. The most intriguing story line (and I haven't been able to keep up with the whole series so maybe there's others I would have liked) was when the son of the guy who died on her operating table…

If that was the intent, it's degenerated in reality. I was reading some of Todd
VanDerWerff's old reviews and they're a world away from the tone that
prevails now. Sociopolitical context, sure, but also assessing within
a cultural and creative context. More and more it's descending to
dogma and they seem to want to…

Are we talking "accuracy and faithfulness"? Because Watson admired Sherlock to the point of embarrassment, something that doesn't play well regardless of gender these days. Each iteration gets to translate the series as they like. I happen to be fine with one that's updated to New York City with a female Watson. I…