My list (who reads these comments newest first by the way?)
No numerical ranking:

Immaculate Songwriting is Just Not Enough To Get an A
There are few songwriters half as good as Neil Finn, yet most reviewers - this one included - still hedge their marks of Crowded House for some reason. "They have REALLY GOOD SONGWRITING but it's got this fresh layer of wallpaper it doesn't need." Huh? Same…

Major Omission
"Idiot Wind"

You people need to learn to listen to Midlake and love them as you should.

I care
Who cares?

Crowded House let down
Yes - Ice Cream! is correct - it wasn't a technical malfunction that caused the interruption in "Don't Dream It's Over," it was the crass behavior of the RATM fans - pegging the mic and Neil Finn with a water bottle. Beyond that, the crowd continued to chant "Rage! Rage! Rage!" in between songs…

Half Nelson
I'm really surprised Half Nelson is nowhere to be found on this list.