This article is doomed by the second sentence. "It’s the most over-praised entry in television’s present golden age" is a statement that comes as an implicit, sneering insult to its entire fanbase, basically saying "all these people who love it are just WRONG." It's basically impossible to go right when you start off…

Well, yeah. I thought it was a stupid premise. But I didn't really find anything wrong with the way it was pulled off.

I don't get you guys. I don't understand how anyone can feel this strong a hatred towards this. It really makes absolutely no sense to me. I laughed, gave it a B+, whatever. But there is nothing in this episode that should make you feel strongly enough to hate this.

Utah delenda est.

Yeah, this has been bothering me for a while.

What? A-, VanDerWerff! Booo!

I liked it way better than last week's, which I was mostly "eh" about. I give it extra points because it was clearly trying something new and being interesting to watch. A-

People giving this episode an F are literally insane. I don't know what to say, but that's just not what that's for. You guys felt way, waaaay too strongly about this, holy crap.

I did see Blue Man Group, I didn't get it! Why can't they talk? They have so much in common!

I enjoyed this episode more than most others this season. Didn't make me laugh a ton, but a really good episode nonetheless.

This is acceptable.

A-. Seriously, VanDerWerff?

Except that's not true.

Seriously. I don't understand anyone calling either of the last two episodes the worst of the show. It makes absolutely no sense to me.

I think I just prefer the idea of them airing a Halloween episode on Valentine's Day, even if unintentional.

This episode was good and you're all wrong.

Season 2 had all of the worst episodes of the show's run. Season 3 is the best one. Season 4 isn't bad. I feel like I'm watching a different show than the rest of you.

Yeah, but that run has The Psychology of Letting Go (only an okay episode) and ABEEEEEEEEED in it. Epidemiology to ABC, that's a great, dense run.

This is a B- minimum. C-? What? That's just crazy. I liked it more than a few Season 2 episodes.

Change it from what? I don't think they did.