Not a commentator as a rule, but this thread really gets to me—these guys are legitimately funny, and the podcast is actually great. It's not them crapping on the movie every week, it's more them talking about the experience of watching the same thing over and over, and trying to find new things to say about it. …

Jesus people!

I always liked this one, it's got a good arc. And I love that bit at the end, with Homer telling Marge "If we raised three kids kids who can hog-tie a stranger we must have been doing something right" or something similar. I like A- as the grade for it.

No no no, the underlying theme of the post is "a good deed is its own reward".

The exclusion of HALO from this list is PROOF POSITIVE that the AV Club hates video games and gamers. Their continued pretence of enjoyment of said games is simply a ruse to infuriate us all. Because they hate us too.

Jeanne D'arc was awesome, and I too graduated from that to ff tactics. Anyone then give Disgeae a go? I thought I'd love it, but I just couldn't get into it, and have tried three times now.

Oh yes, COH is amazing. Buy it now. So, so good.

What I loved the most is that as a New Zealander I could manage our one team 'The Phoenix' (WHICH IS INCLUDED!!!!!) and take them all the way to number one. Took me a few seasons though, but building a New Zealand soccer dynasty was always going to take time.

Well a deals a deal, so I guess I'll go drag it out and give it another crack. This time I'll keep in mind its place in history and its influence on other games, particularly the mechanics, which in hindsight were remarkably good, especially compared to RE1,2,3.

Resident Evil 4
Why are people arguing for the inclusion of this one? I would rate RE1+2 as among my top 5 all time games, but RE4 doesn't do it for me. It was like, RE for people who found the first ones too slow or something. There was no atmosphere, no exploration, no sense of another world like the first one…

Thanks for the tip, am downloading Fate of Empires as I type this.

*Heart of Darkness

1 San Andreas, if only because of Mary Beth
2 Braid
3 Ico
4 Far Cry, for its 'Hearts of Darkness' groove
5 Counter Strike, for getting me into online multiplay (it's older than 2000 though, right?)
6 Gran Turismo 4. Always a classic.
7 Something from Popcap, I don't really care what. The new one, Gyromancer? Peggle? …

Fun domestic violence themed platformer
You play the wives!

fun platformer about domestic violence
http://phuce.com/uploads/qu…

Oh oh! Are we going to argue over whether ZMF is legit/not legit, and if so, is his schtick still funny/was never funny, and once we've decided that, whether the people who like/liked his schtick liked it for honest reasons, or whther they were just following the crowd?

fascinating
Although I believe the lyric is "Let the beat build, BEEEETCH".

Buffy's TV Club is Back!
That is the best news I have heard all week. I am so happy.

Definitely 'whom', since the 'you' is doing the doing.
Personally I'd say "a person unknown by you", that's just me.
Let's continue this discussion.

What is going on? Are they expecting me to go to ournewmovie.com and sit through all the bullshit just to watch a trailer that I was only going to watch because I'm procrastinating. Is this meant to be one of those 'event' movies?
And copyright on a trailer ffs? What are they afraid of, that the AV club will pass it…